#64 Cream- Goodbye
It’s hello from them and, erm…goodbye from them…
(Polydor)

Released: February 5th 1969
Producer: Felix Pappalardi
Topped the chart:
9th March 1969 (for 2 weeks)
6th April 1969 (for 1 week)
20th April 1969 (for 1 week)
4 weeks total
Sgt Pepper and the work of the Jimi Hendrix Experience are often credited with the birth of “serious” Rolling Stone-approved rock music. However, British band Cream can have a claim (or blame?) at parentage too. Often cited as the first “supergroup”—with apologies to the Million Dollar Quartet—blues boomers Jack Bruce, Eric Clapton and Ginger Baker came together in a way that one always hopes such ventures will: take the best of their previous work and up their game together.
We meet Cream at the end of their time as a group. Having hit big with second album, 1967’s psychedelic swirl Disraeli Gears and its attendant single Sunshine of Your Love, it’s a far cry from the band recording Goodbye.
The name says it all: this was to be the finale, after tensions between Bruce and Baker on tour became too much to hear. Rather than celebration and culmination, Goodbye whiffs more than a little of contractual obligation, backed up by pretty much every article you could read on the album talking about the band being “convinced” to record one final LP.
As a result, it’s a step down (or a Bringdown, if you will) from the sprawling double-set of 1968, with one disc of high quality new material, and the other highlighting the band as a supreme live act. On the latter point, by accounts the tour in support of that album changed things: Clapton recalled that everyone was playing as loud as possible and “showing off” to the audience—he also recalled one concert where he stopped playing, and his bandmates failed to notice.
This is evidenced on the three live tracks here, cut from a show at the Forum in Los Angeles. Sitting on the Top of the World suffers with bass so loud it buzzes from the speakers and swamping everything around it. It and the uninspired Politician are ground down to sludge, both are slow, lumbering, dreary blues tracks that don’t represent the supergroup at their best.
Better is the extended opening track I’m So Glad, running to nine minutes—this is the Hendrix era, after all. It doesn’t fizz with the same creativity and energy that Jimi’s best live work does, and certainly outstays its welcome, but it’s the one live cut where the superstars feel in sync.
The remaining three studio recordings fare better: they’re still a little throwaway and certainly aren’t up to the standard set by the likes of Sunshine, I Feel Free or Crossroads, but they remind you that the band members had a way with a nice little pop song. This is particularly true for Badge, a peppy Clapton co-write with one Mr G Harrison who apparently did rather well with another band of the era. Clapton’s misty vocals work well with the Strange Brew-ish atmosphere, spine-tingling piano filling the spaces between the oblique lyrics (“I told you 'bout the swans, that they live in the park.” Closer What A Bringdown revels in a sinister carnival atmosphere, Hammond Organ whirling as Baker pounds hard on the percussion.
It’s proof that there is life and creativity here, but at just half an hour and six tracks, there isn’t nearly enough of it. If you have a tear in your eye saying Goodbye to a legendary 60s band, you’re best off revisiting pretty much any of their other records.
Score: 5/10
Tracklisting:
SIDE A
1. I’m So Glad (Live)
2. Politician (Live)
SIDE B
3. Sitting On Top of the World (Live)
4. Badge
5. Doing That Scrapyard Thing
6. What a Bringdown




Comments